The Adjuster Was an Algorithm: The Policyholder's Bad-Faith Case Against AI Claim Handling
On-Demand · 2 CLE credits · November 12, 2026, 12:00 PM ET
An insurer cannot outsource its duty of good faith to a machine. Plead algorithmic claim handling as unreasonable conduct, trace the AI decision chain to the claim outcome, and compel the scores, audit trails, and override logs behind it.
The Claim File Is No Longer Only What the Adjuster Saw
The old question was what the adjuster was thinking. Insurers now run automated triage, severity scoring, settlement recommendations, and claim denials. The Oklahoma AG alleges that AI systems were used to undervalue claims and raise closure rates. The new question is what the algorithm was designed to do.
Biased inputs are a biased investigation. Automated undervaluation is a settlement untethered from actual damages. Optimization goals that reward lower payouts are designed misconduct, not adjuster error. Rubber-stamping the model is a failure to supervise it. Each theory tests unreasonable claim handling, inadequate investigation, and reckless disregard of the insured's interests.
You leave with four pleading theories and a causation chain that connects the technology to the claim. You leave with discovery requests built by category, deposition topics by witness, and answers to the black-box defense. Judgment calls, not doctrine.
Key topics
- Duty Follows the Algorithm: How an insurer cannot outsource its duty of good faith to a machine, and why an algorithm that performs the adjuster’s function becomes evidence of the insurer’s own claim-handling conduct.
- AG Allegations as Roadmap: How the Oklahoma AG allegations — that insurers used AI systems to systematically undervalue claims, make settlement offers below fair value, raise closure rates, and prioritize profit over accuracy — create a factual narrative and make internal documents discoverable in private litigation.
- Four Bad-Faith Theories: How to translate AI conduct into unreasonable claim handling under four theories: biased inputs as a biased investigation, algorithmic undervaluation, institutionalized claims minimization as designed misconduct rather than adjuster error, and failure to supervise the system.
- Causation and Reasonableness: How to trace the AI decision chain from data ingestion through score generation to claim outcome, and what a jury must answer: whether a reasonable insurer would rely on the algorithm, whether its limitations were known, and whether its outputs were ever tested for accuracy.
- Compelling the AI File: How to answer “show me everything that influenced the claim decision” by category — system architecture, claim-specific AI data, performance validation, corporate knowledge — and what belongs in the AI claims file, from risk scores and audit trails to override logs and model-generated communications.
- Depositions and Defenses: How to build corporate-representative topics for claims, data science, compliance, and vendor witnesses, and how to answer the black-box defense with attorneys'-eyes-only designations, source-code review protocols, and proportionality limits tied to the claim.
Agenda
- SESSION 1: Turning the Oklahoma AG Suits into a Policyholder Bad-Faith Case
- SESSION 2: Discovering the Algorithm: Compelling the Insurer's AI Claim-Handling File
Faculty
- Michael S. Levine, Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP
- Karin S. Aldama, Gallagher & Kennedy
State accreditation
- AK: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AL: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- AR: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AZ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CO: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- CT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- DC: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- DE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- FL: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 General Hours
- GA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- HI: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- IA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ID: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- IL: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- IN: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- KS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 Substantive
- KY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- LA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MA: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- ME: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MI: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MN: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MO: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2.4 General
- MS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ND: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NH: Approved for CLE Credits, 120 General minutes
- NJ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NM: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- NV: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NY: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- OH: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- OK: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- OR: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- PA: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- RI: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- SC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- SD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- TN: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- TX: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- UT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- VA: Not Eligible, 2 General Hours
- VT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- WA: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 Law & Legal Hours
- WI: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- WV: Pending CLE Approval, 2.4 General
- WY: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General