Vacating Arbitration Awards After Jules: Jurisdiction, Deadlines, and Practical Strategies
Live · 2 CLE credits · December 3, 2026, 12:00 PM ET
Pick the wrong court or miss the FAA deadline, and your award challenge dies unheard. Choose the forum after Jules, protect the three-month clock, and plead grounds that survive deference.
A Winning Vacatur Argument Means Nothing in the Wrong Court or After the Deadline
Challenging an arbitration award now starts with a jurisdiction question. When federal courts can hear post-award motions turns on Badgerow and Smith v. Spizzirri. The Supreme Court's 2026 decision in Jules v. Andre Balazs Properties then resolved the post-Badgerow circuit split on federal jurisdiction. The dispute's procedural history now shapes where a challenge can be heard.
Pick the wrong forum, and the motion may never be heard. Miss the FAA Section 12 three-month deadline, and the challenge may be lost. Allege evident partiality, misconduct, or fraud under Section 10 without supporting evidence, and judicial deference wins. Lean on manifest disregard, and you meet its limits and jurisdictional differences. Fail to preserve objections, and the issue may not survive appeal.
You leave able to assess the appropriate forum after Jules and to calculate and protect the three-month deadline. You also learn to evaluate potential vacatur grounds, develop supporting evidence, and build the record. Then you frame a motion that addresses the limits of judicial review. Each step is a judgment call tied to your own dispute's procedural history and record, which no generic template makes for you.
Key topics
- Choosing the Right Court: How Jules, Badgerow, and Smith v. Spizzirri, applied to the underlying case and its jurisdictional basis, decide whether a federal court can hear your post-award motion.
- Beating the Three-Month Clock: How to calculate the FAA Section 12 three-month deadline to vacate and protect your challenge from the deadline and filing errors that end it early.
- Proving Exceeded Arbitrator Authority: How to identify arbitrator decisions that reach beyond the arbitrator’s authority and turn them into a vacatur argument that overcomes judicial deference.
- Proving Partiality and Misconduct: How to evaluate evident partiality, arbitrator misconduct, and fraud under FAA Section 10 and develop the supporting evidence each ground demands.
- Testing Manifest Disregard Limits: How the limits of manifest disregard, and its differences from one jurisdiction to the next, should decide whether and how you raise it.
- Preserving Issues for Appeal: How filing strategy, a well-built record, preserved objections, and a carefully framed motion keep your appellate options open and avoid procedural pitfalls.
Agenda
- Selecting the forum and preserving the right to challenge an award
- Building a viable challenge under deferential judicial review
Faculty
- Bruce J. Berman, Carlton Fields
- James S. Czodli, Carlton Fields
State accreditation
- AK: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AL: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AR: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AZ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CO: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- CT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- DC: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- DE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- FL: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 General Hours
- GA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- HI: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- IA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ID: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- IL: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- IN: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- KS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 Substantive
- KY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- LA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MA: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- ME: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MI: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MN: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MO: Approved for CLE Credits, 2.4 General
- MS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ND: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NH: Approved for CLE Credits, 120 General minutes
- NJ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NM: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NV: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NY: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- OH: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- OK: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- OR: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- PA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- RI: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- SC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- SD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- TN: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- TX: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- UT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- VA: Not Eligible, 2 General Hours
- VT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- WA: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 Law & Legal Hours
- WI: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- WV: Pending CLE Approval, 2.4 General
- WY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General