ERISA Disability Claimant Counsel: Keeping Benefits Past the 24-Month Mental-Health Limitation with Physical-Causation Proof
Live · 2 CLE credits · December 21, 2026, 2:30 PM ET
LTD insurers increasingly cap benefits at 24 months whenever a file mentions depression or anxiety. Build the physical-causation record before it closes, rebut reviewer reports in time, and litigate the limitation in federal court without conceding the psychiatric frame.
A single psychiatric label can cut a disability claim off at 24 months
Long-term disability insurers increasingly invoke the 24-month mental-health limitation whenever a file mentions depression, anxiety, or another behavioral-health condition. Courts in the Sixth and Eighth Circuits apply a but-for test, under which the mere presence of a mental condition does not trigger the cap. Elsewhere, deferential review and the plan's wording can decide the case.
Let a treater's causation opinion arrive after the limitation notice, and Gill shows a court may discount it. Leave psychiatric labels and reviewer reports unanswered, and Hall shows how a brain-injury claim is lost. Overlook the insurer's own reinstatement letter, and McEachin shows you have missed evidence of when the clock started. Plead the case in psychiatric terms, and you may concede the limitation before the court reads the record.
You walk out with intake checklists, template letters to treating providers, and a response matrix for reviewer reports. You also get a decision tree for the standard of review and the clock arguments, and a complaint and brief checklist. These are claimant-side judgment calls the case law alone does not make for you.
Key topics
- Setting the Proof Target: How but-for causation and the plan’s wording set the proof target, and what Gill, Hall, and Krash show about late opinions, psychiatric labels, and unanswered reviewers.
- Intake and Treater Opinions: How to sequence intake to avoid the diagnosis-labeling trap, and how to obtain treating-provider causation opinions and Attending Physician Statements that hold up.
- Testing and the Physical Record: How neuropsychological testing, functional capacity evaluations, and occupational evidence support physical causation, and how to date the physical record through continuous treatment and the carrier’s own letters.
- Reviewer Reports and SSDI: How to demand and rebut reviewer reports under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(4) inside the appeal window, and how a parallel SSDI claim and its offset fit the plan.
- Reading the Denial and the Plan: How to read the denial for comorbidity versus etiology, map plan wording and circuit law, and work the standard-of-review fork created by discretionary clauses, state bans, and governing-law clauses.
- The Clock and the Remedy: How to sequence never-started and tolling arguments, draft the complaint and opening brief without conceding the psychiatric frame, and choose reinstatement or remand before the fee petition.
Agenda
- Building the Physical-Causation Record for LTD Claims Facing the Mental-Health Limitation
- Litigating the 24-Month Mental-Health Limitation on the Claimant’s Side in Federal Court
Faculty
- Mark D. DeBofsky, DeBofsky Law, Ltd
State accreditation
- AK: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AL: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AR: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AZ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CO: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- CT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- DC: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- DE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- FL: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 General Hours
- GA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- HI: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- IA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ID: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- IL: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- IN: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- KS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 Substantive
- KY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- LA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MA: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- ME: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MI: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MN: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MO: Approved for CLE Credits, 2.4 General
- MS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ND: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NH: Approved for CLE Credits, 120 General minutes
- NJ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NM: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NV: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NY: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- OH: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- OK: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- OR: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- PA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- RI: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- SC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- SD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- TN: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- TX: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- UT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- VA: Not Eligible, 2 General Hours
- VT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- WA: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 Law & Legal Hours
- WI: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- WV: Pending CLE Approval, 2.4 General
- WY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General