On-Demand · June 13, 2025

Dissecting an Undue Influence Claim: From Intake to Appeal

Navigate undue influence claims from intake to trial, covering evidence strategies, expert witnesses, mediation tactics, and courtroom presentation.

Paul R. Shugar Reminger Co. LPA

About this program

Course Overview

Mastering Undue Influence Claims in Probate

Participants will learn to evaluate, litigate, and resolve undue influence claims from initial client intake through trial. These strategies help attorneys navigate discovery, depositions, mediation, and courtroom presentation effectively.

  • Client Evaluation Assess potential clients and identify red flags.
  • Discovery Strategies Obtain critical financial and medical evidence.
  • Mediation Preparation Prepare clients for realistic settlement negotiations.
  • Trial Presentation Present simple themes that persuade fact finders.

Why Attend

Understanding undue influence claims is essential for practitioners because these fact-intensive probate cases are increasing as the aging population grows and trillions in wealth transfer between generations.

  • $27B Reported elder financial exploitation suspicious activity detected by financial institutions in a one-year period ending June 2023.
  • $84T Estimated wealth that baby boomers and the silent generation will transfer to heirs and charities through 2045 in the Great Wealth Transfer.
  • 1/24 Cases of elder abuse that are actually reported to adult protective services or law enforcement authorities, leaving most incidents hidden.
  • 1in5 Americans projected to be age 65 or older by 2030, dramatically expanding the vulnerable population susceptible to undue influence.

Key Topics

  • Client Intake Evaluate potential clients as witnesses and identify red flags signaling undue influence.
  • Legal Elements Understand susceptibility, opportunity, and exertion requirements for proving undue influence claims.
  • Discovery Strategies Obtain estate planning files, medical records, and financial documents through subpoenas.
  • Depositions Take depositions that serve as functional trials and damage witness credibility.
  • Mediation Prepare clients realistically for settlement negotiations considering case economics and risks.
  • Trial Presentation Keep arguments simple with clear themes that connect with judges and juries.

What You Will Learn and Gain

What you will learn

Attorneys will learn how to handle undue influence claims from initial client intake through discovery, mediation strategies, and trial presentation techniques.

What you will gain

Attorneys will gain practical strategies for evaluating case economics, obtaining critical evidence, taking effective depositions, and presenting compelling arguments to judges and juries.

Speakers

Paul R. Shugar

Paul R. Shugar

Reminger Co. LPA

Shareholder and Co-Chair of Reminger’s Estates, Trusts, and Probate Litigation Practice Group with statewide experience involving million-dollar estate, trust, and guardianship issues including undue influence, power of attorney abuse, and financial exploitation. Former award-winning journalist who applies writing and investigation skills to maximize litigation results.

Full profile

Experience

Statewide experience handling million-dollar estate, trust, and guardianship issues. Has guided clients through post-death land, corporate, divorce, and oil-and-gas lease disputes. Regularly lectures on estate and trust administration and litigation topics across Ohio.

Recognition

Award-winning journalist who worked at daily newspapers around the country before becoming a lawyer.

Professional involvement

Officer for the Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association's Estate Planning, Probate & Trust Law Section. Member of the Ohio State Bar Association Probate Trust and Estate Section Council.

Agenda

  1. Session 1 · 1:00 pm - 1:30 pm

    Understanding Key Elements of Undue Influence Claims

    This session explores the foundational elements of undue influence claims, including susceptibility, opportunity through confidential relationships, and the challenge of proving exertion of influence. Participants will examine common red flags, statute of limitations considerations, and why these cases are becoming increasingly relevant as demographic shifts accelerate wealth transfer.

    Paul R. Shugar

  2. Session 2 · 1:30 pm - 2:00 pm

    Litigation Strategies and Evidence Gathering Techniques

    This session covers essential discovery strategies including obtaining financial records, estate planning attorney files, and medical documentation from diverse sources. Participants will learn effective deposition tactics, how to evaluate case economics, and the strategic use of expert witnesses in building or defending undue influence cases.

    Paul R. Shugar

  3. Session 3 · 2:10 pm - 2:40 pm

    Mediation Settlement and Trial Presentation Approaches

    This session examines realistic approaches to mediation preparation, including how to present compelling evidence and manage client expectations about settlement outcomes. Participants will also explore trial techniques focused on simplicity, credibility, and thematic storytelling that resonates with judges and juries.

    Paul R. Shugar

MCLE Credits

  • Alabama

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Alaska

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.

  • Arizona

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • Arkansas

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • California

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • Colorado

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Connecticut

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • Delaware

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • District of Columbia

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Florida

    Approved via Attorney Submission

    1.5 General Hours

    Receive CLE credit in Florida via Attorney Submission.

  • Georgia

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • Hawaii

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • Idaho

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Illinois

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • Indiana

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Iowa

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Kansas

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Substantive

  • Kentucky

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Louisiana

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Maine

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Maryland

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Massachusetts

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Michigan

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Minnesota

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • Mississippi

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Missouri

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.8 General

  • Montana

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • Nebraska

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

    myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.

  • Nevada

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • New Hampshire

    Approved for CLE Credits

    90 Minutes

    As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.

  • New Jersey

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2

  • New Mexico

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • New York

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.

  • North Carolina

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • North Dakota

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14

  • Ohio

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • Oklahoma

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Oregon

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Pennsylvania

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • Rhode Island

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • South Carolina

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • South Dakota

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Tennessee

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Texas

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Utah

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General

  • Vermont

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 General

  • Virginia

    Not Eligible

    1.5 General Hours

  • Washington

    Approved via Attorney Submission

    1.5 Law & Legal Hours

    Receive CLE credit in Washington via Attorney Submission. myLawCLE will supply Washington state attorneys with instructions on how to gain credit.

  • West Virginia

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.8 General

  • Wisconsin

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

  • Wyoming

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 General