On-Demand · July 10, 2025
Insurance Coverage Issues Under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act
Insurance coverage analysis for civil claims under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act, examining applicable policies, defenses, and key decisions.
K. James Sullivan Calfee, Halter & GriswoldMatthew A. Chiricosta Calfee, Halter & GriswoldTae Andrews Calfee, Halter & Griswold
About this program
Course Overview
Navigating TVPRA Insurance Coverage Disputes
Participants will learn to identify available insurance coverages and evaluate common exclusions when defending TVPRA civil claims. Practical strategies for securing defense and indemnity coverage will be emphasized.
- Coverage Options Evaluate CGL, E&O, and EPLI policies.
- Policy Exclusions Analyze assault, molestation, and intent exclusions.
- Defense Strategies Apply duty to defend standards effectively.
- Key Precedents Interpret leading TVPRA coverage case law.
Why Attend
Understanding TVPRA insurance coverage issues is essential because record verdict amounts and surging civil claims create unprecedented liability exposure for hospitality businesses and their insurers.
- 1.2k+ Total federal TVPRA civil cases filed from 2003 through December 2024, according to the Human Trafficking Legal Center.
- $40M Largest TVPRA jury verdict in U.S. history, awarded in July 2025 against United Inn in Georgia—the first hotel case to reach jury verdict under the statute.
- 80% Percentage of commercial sex trafficking acts that occurred at hotels, according to a Polaris Project survivor survey.
- 280 Number of new TVPRA civil cases filed in 2024 alone, representing a record-breaking annual total according to the Human Trafficking Legal Center.
Key Topics
- TVPRA Overview Federal statute allowing trafficking victims to sue businesses that knowingly benefited from violations.
- Coverage Types CGL, E&O, and EPLI policies may provide defense and indemnity for TVPRA claims.
- Common Exclusions Insurers rely on assault, abuse, expected injury, and knowing violation exclusions to deny coverage.
- Defense Standards Duty to defend is triggered if any potential coverage exists under the complaint's allegations.
- Key Decisions Courts in Northfield, Riccio, and Travelers cases found insurers owed defense to policyholders.
- Insurability Question Pennsylvania Supreme Court will decide if public policy bars coverage for trafficking-related claims.
What You Will Learn and Gain
What you will learn
Attorneys will learn how courts analyze insurance coverage disputes for TVPRA civil claims, including key exclusions, duty to defend standards, and recent judicial decisions.
What you will gain
Attorneys will gain practical strategies for evaluating CGL, E&O, and EPLI policies when advising clients facing human trafficking litigation or coverage disputes.
Speakers
K. James Sullivan
Calfee, Halter & Griswold
Leader of Calfee’s Insurance Recovery practice who counsels corporate insurance policyholders on insurance coverage issues and litigates insurance coverage disputes, with primary focus on closely held and publicly traded corporate policyholders.
Full profile
Experience
Leads Calfee's Insurance Recovery practice, providing insurance coverage services to closely held and publicly traded corporate policyholders on a variety of matters.
Matthew A. Chiricosta
Calfee, Halter & Griswold
Member of Calfee’s Insurance Recovery practice providing insurance coverage advisory and litigation services to policyholders across various insurance products including CGL, D&O, E&O, and property insurance.
Full profile
Experience
Deep experience litigating complex insurance disputes on behalf of policyholders. Brings a proactive and cost-effective problem-solving approach to resolving complex insurance coverage matters and recovering insurance policy proceeds for policyholders.
Tae Andrews
Calfee, Halter & Griswold
Experienced member of Calfee’s Insurance Coverage practice team who advises corporate insurance policyholders in multiple industries and litigates complex insurance disputes in both state and federal courts.
Full profile
Experience
Focuses on advising corporate policyholders on insurance coverage issues arising under commercial general liability, directors and officers, professional liability/errors and omissions, excess, umbrella, and other types of policies. Has a track record of delivering successful results for clients with D&O, E&O, Property and General Liability Insurance claims.Agenda
-
TVPRA Overview and Civil Cause of Action
This session provides a comprehensive overview of the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act, tracing its evolution from a 2000 criminal statute to the 2003 addition of a private civil cause of action. Participants will learn how the 2008 expansion created liability for those who knowingly benefit from trafficking ventures, triggering a wave of litigation against hospitality-industry businesses.
K. James Sullivan, Matthew A. Chiricosta, Tae Andrews
-
Recent Trends in TVPRA Case Law
This session examines emerging trends in TVPRA litigation, including the landmark Apple case addressing venture definitions and extraterritoriality. Participants will explore how courts have interpreted the statute’s application to global supply chains and the ongoing efforts to consolidate cases through multi-district litigation.
K. James Sullivan, Matthew A. Chiricosta, Tae Andrews
-
Insurance Coverage Types for TVPRA Civil Claims
This session analyzes the multiple insurance policies that may respond to TVPRA claims, including Commercial General Liability, Errors & Omissions, and Employment Practices Liability coverage. Participants will learn about coverage hooks such as bodily injury, personal injury offenses like false imprisonment, and third-party discrimination coverage.
K. James Sullivan, Matthew A. Chiricosta, Tae Andrews
-
Break
A brief intermission allowing participants to refresh before the final sessions. Use this time to review materials and prepare questions for the upcoming coverage defense analysis.
K. James Sullivan, Matthew A. Chiricosta, Tae Andrews
-
Insurers' Coverage Defenses and Key Policy Exclusions
This session explores the primary defenses insurers assert when denying TVPRA coverage, including expected or intended injury, abuse and molestation, and assault and battery exclusions. Participants will examine the critical distinction between the duty to defend and duty to indemnify, and how the TVPRA’s negligence-based standard affects exclusion applicability.
K. James Sullivan, Matthew A. Chiricosta, Tae Andrews
-
Key Insurance Coverage Case Law for TVPRA
This session surveys pivotal judicial decisions shaping TVPRA insurance coverage, including Northfield, Riccio v. Bijal, Travelers v. Salesforce, and the Samsung case. Participants will analyze how courts have interpreted policy language and the emerging public policy debate over insurability of trafficking-related claims.
K. James Sullivan, Matthew A. Chiricosta, Tae Andrews
MCLE Credits
-
Alabama
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Alaska
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.
-
Arizona
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
Arkansas
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
California
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
Colorado
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Connecticut
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
Delaware
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
District of Columbia
No MCLE Required
1.5 CLE Hour(s)
-
Florida
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General Hours
Receive CLE credit in Florida via Attorney Submission.
-
Georgia
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
Hawaii
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
Idaho
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Illinois
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.5 General
-
Indiana
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Iowa
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Kansas
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 Substantive
-
Kentucky
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Louisiana
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Maine
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Maryland
No MCLE Required
1.5 CLE Hour(s)
-
Massachusetts
No MCLE Required
1.5 CLE Hour(s)
-
Michigan
No MCLE Required
1.5 CLE Hour(s)
-
Minnesota
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.5 General
-
Mississippi
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Missouri
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.8 General
-
Montana
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Nebraska
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.
-
Nevada
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.5 General
-
New Hampshire
Approved for CLE Credits
90 General minutes
As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.
-
New Jersey
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2
-
New Mexico
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.5 General
-
New York
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.
-
North Carolina
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
North Dakota
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14
-
Ohio
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Oklahoma
Pending CLE Approval
2 General
-
Oregon
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Pennsylvania
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.5 General
-
Rhode Island
Pending CLE Approval
2 General
-
South Carolina
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
South Dakota
No MCLE Required
1.5 CLE Hour(s)
-
Tennessee
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Texas
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Utah
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
-
Vermont
Approved for CLE Credits
1.5 General
-
Virginia
Not Eligible
1.5 General Hours
-
Washington
Approved via Attorney Submission
1.5 Law & Legal Hours
Receive CLE credit in Washington via Attorney Submission. myLawCLE will supply Washington state attorneys with instructions on how to gain credit.
-
West Virginia
Pending CLE Approval
1.8 General
-
Wisconsin
Approved for Self-Study Credits
1.5 General
-
Wyoming
Pending CLE Approval
1.5 General
No state matches.