Live Video-Broadcast · December 8, 2026

Pleading the Sexual Harassment Count That Keeps the Plaintiff’s Whole Employment Case Out of Arbitration

One thin harassment count can send a plaintiff's whole employment case into arbitration. Learn to draft the count to survive plausibility review inside the motion to compel. Defend the EFAA's whole-case exemption against severance and joinder attacks, and answer each employer argument with complaint allegations.

2:30 - 4:40 PM EST 1:30 - 3:40 PM CST 12:30 - 2:40 PM MST 11:30 AM - 1:40 PM PST

Andrew H. Friedman Helmer Friedman LLPJohn S. Crain Seppinni Law

About this program

Course Overview

Under the EFAA, the harassment count is the whole case’s ticket out of arbitration — and employers now attack it first

The Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (9 U.S.C. §§ 401-402) exempts whole cases from arbitration, not just the harassment claim. Employers have answered by arguing that the harassment count is too thin to qualify. Some courts now apply plausibility review inside the motion to compel under 9 U.S.C. § 402(a). Bruce v. Adams and Reese, Kutagula v. Matterport, and Ai v. Tencent show how much the pleading matters.

Plead gender-based hostility without sexual overtures, and the Ding, Singh, Einkorn, and Decloedt split decides whether the EFAA applies at all. Join plaintiffs who lack a harassment dispute, or plead a class, and the employer will push them toward arbitration. Treat “alleging” as “stating a claim,” and a 12(b)(6)-style Iqbal review becomes the gate. Plead retaliation for a harassment complaint, and Olivieri keeps it inside the “dispute.”

Andrew H. Friedman and John Crain cover both fronts. Draft the count to the plausibility standard even where a non-frivolous test may apply. Hold the whole-case exemption against severance, joinder, and class-action attacks after Diaz-Roa. Attendees leave with a paragraph-by-paragraph drafting checklist, an opposition decision tree, and an argument outline answering each employer argument with specific complaint allegations.

Key Topics

  • Pleading Standard and “Alleging” Whether the gate is “plausible” or merely “non-frivolous,” why to draft to the plausibility standard anyway, and why the EFAA’s word “alleging” is not “stating a claim” under 12(b)(6) and Iqbal.
  • Gender and Orientation Coverage Whether harassment on the basis of gender devoid of any sexual comments or overtures triggers the EFAA — the split among Ding, Singh, Einkorn, and Decloedt — and whether the Act reaches sexual orientation harassment.
  • Reading the Exemplar Complaints What courts found on the page in Kerim, Bruce, Ai v. Tencent, and Kutagula when plaintiffs satisfied, or failed, the plausibility standard, and what that means for your next complaint.
  • Whole Case Versus Specific Claims Whether the EFAA’s protections apply to an entire “case” or only to specific “claims,” the Second, Sixth, and Ninth Circuit consensus, and how Diaz-Roa cuts off attempts to split off unrelated wage and labor claims.
  • Joined Plaintiffs and Class Actions What happens when joined plaintiffs lack a sexual harassment or sexual assault dispute, whether courts can sever under Rule 7, and how the “named representative of a class” text reads for class actions.
  • Dispute Scope and Waiver How far a “dispute” reaches beyond the harassment claim itself — retaliation under Olivieri, investigation witnesses, the accused harasser’s defamation suit — and whether a plaintiff may waive rights under the EFAA.

Speakers

Andrew H. Friedman

Andrew H. Friedman

Helmer Friedman LLP

Andrew H. Friedman is a founding and name partner of Helmer Friedman LLP, where he prosecutes workplace harassment, discrimination, retaliation, whistleblowing, wrongful termination, and wage-and-hour cases on behalf of employees; forced arbitration and sexual harassment are among the practice areas his firm lists for him. He is the co-author, with Anthony J. Oncidi, of The Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act: Four Years Fraught with Confusion and Litigation, published in the Journal of the Litigation Section of the California Lawyers Association (Vol. 38, No. 3, 2025), and the author of the two-volume treatise Litigating Employment Discrimination Cases (James Publishing, 2005–2026). He also serves as a mediator in litigated and non-litigated employment matters.

Full profile

Experience

Mr. Friedman’s harassment and discrimination matters include co-counseling a $12 million settlement for former California State University administrators in gender-harassment, discrimination, and retaliation litigation; serving on the trial team that won a $6 million jury verdict for Dr. Anissa Rogers in gender discrimination, harassment, and retaliation litigation against California State University; an $8 million pre-litigation resolution of a discrimination, harassment, and retaliation matter; and a three-week sexual-harassment jury trial in Orange County Superior Court that he and his partner Gregory D. Helmer won before the case resolved on a confidential basis. He has also obtained a $4.1 million jury verdict in an employment-related fraud and breach-of-contract action and class-action recoveries of $2.4 million, $1.575 million, and $1.5 million. As counsel of record in Lightfoot v. Cendant Mortgage Corp., he successfully petitioned the United States Supreme Court and, in January 2017, won a unanimous reversal of the Ninth Circuit in an opinion by Justice Sonia Sotomayor. His other publications include The Top Employment Cases of 2025, 2024, and 2023 (Cal. Lab. & Emp. L. Rev.) and McDonnell Douglas: The End Is Near? (Cal. Lab. & Emp. L. Rev., September 2025).

Education

Mr. Friedman earned his J.D. from Cornell Law School, where he served as an editor of the Cornell Law Review and a member of the Moot Court Board, and his B.A. in History and Psychology, cum laude, from Vanderbilt University. He clerked for the Honorable John T. Nixon of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee and practiced as an associate at Paul Hastings and Bryan Cave before founding his current firm. He is admitted in California, Missouri, and the District of Columbia, and before the California federal district courts, the Ninth Circuit, and the United States Supreme Court.

Recognition

Chambers USA ranks Mr. Friedman in Band 1, its highest tier, for plaintiff-side labor and employment law in California, and ranks Helmer Friedman LLP as a Band 1 California plaintiff employment firm. Martindale-Hubbell has given him its AV Preeminent peer-review rating. Super Lawyers has named him among the Top 100 lawyers in Southern California each year from 2020 through 2026, and The Best Lawyers in America has recognized him in Labor and Employment Law each year from 2019 through 2026. He is a Fellow of The College of Labor and Employment Lawyers.

Professional involvement

Mr. Friedman is an advisor to the Executive Committee of the Labor and Employment Law Section of the California Lawyers Association and a member of the Executive Committee of the Labor and Employment Law Section of the Los Angeles County Bar Association, where he also serves as Vice-Chair of the Committee on Judicial Appointments. He previously sat on the Executive Committee of the Labor and Employment Law Section of the State Bar of California and on the Board of Directors of the Employment Roundtable of Southern California, and he has served as a Settlement Officer in the Los Angeles Superior Court’s CRASH and LA Resolve mandatory settlement conference programs. His recent speaking engagements include the Employment Law Year in Review for the Labor and Employment Law Section of the California Lawyers Association (July 2025 and July 2026), Motion Practice from A to Z at that section’s New Employment Law Practitioner Conference (January 2026), and the Annual Employment Law Update for the Los Angeles County Bar Association (March 2026).
John S. Crain

John S. Crain

Seppinni Law

John S. Crain is Managing Counsel at Seppinni Law, a New York employment litigation firm whose practice areas include sexual harassment and assault, discrimination and retaliation, pregnancy discrimination, and wage and hour claims. Since completing a federal clerkship he has guided clients through demanding litigation against aggressive opponents, including matters that produced frequently cited precedents, and he has played an important role in confidential settlements of ten to twenty-five million dollars on many occasions.

Full profile

Experience

Mr. Crain’s employment litigation practice includes a record of success in pregnancy discrimination cases, among them a $900,000 judgment in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. His work has included cases that established important and often-cited precedents, and he has played an important role in confidential settlements in the ten-to-twenty-five-million-dollar range.

Education

Mr. Crain graduated summa cum laude and second in his class from Brooklyn Law School, where he was honored seven times for the top score in a lecture course and won the faculty award. After law school he worked in the corporate department of a large New York City firm, and he then clerked for Judge Roslynn Mauskopf of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York.

Recognition

In 2026 Mr. Crain returned to Brooklyn Law School, his alma mater, to teach a seminar on Litigating an Employment Case.

Professional involvement

Before joining Seppinni Law, Mr. Crain was Of Counsel at a prominent New York City civil rights and employment boutique. He has published twice on the history of American civil rights law.

Agenda

  1. 2:30 pm - 3:30 pm

    Drafting the Sexual Harassment Count So It Clears the Arbitration Plausibility Gate

    This session will provide plaintiff-side employment litigators with best practices for drafting the sexual harassment count so that it survives the plausibility review that some courts now apply inside motions to compel arbitration under 9 U.S.C. § 402(a). The hour will cover recent cases including Kerim v. ABM Industries, 2026 WL 2030769 (S.D.N.Y. 2026), Bruce v. Adams and Reese, LLP, 168 F.4th 367 (6th Cir. 2026), Ai v. Tencent America LLC, 2026 WL 2170875 (N.D. Cal. 2026), and Kutagula v. Matterport, Inc., 2026 WL 478343 (N.D.Cal., 2026). It will also discuss the split in authorities regarding whether allegations of gender-based hostility are sufficient to trigger the EFAA including cases such as Ding v. Structure Therapeutics, Inc., 187 F.4th 1231 (9th Cir. 2026), Singh v. Meetup LLC, 750 F. Supp. 3d 250 (S.D.N.Y. 2024), Einkorn v. UMortgage, 2025 WL 3023412 (E.D. Pa. 2025), and Decloedt v. Radnet Mgmt., Inc., 121 Cal. App. 5th 732 (2026).

    Andrew H. Friedman

  2. 3:40 pm - 4:40 pm

    Opposing the Employer's Motion to Compel Arbitration Aimed at the Harassment Count

    This session examines how far the EFAA’s “whole case” exemption reaches once a sexual harassment or sexual assault dispute is alleged. The Act’s plain text exempts whole “cases,” and the Second, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits agree that all claims in the complaint are exempted; the Second Circuit’s Diaz-Roa decision appears to cut off attempts to split off unrelated wage and labor claims, so plaintiffs can argue with some confidence that there is no limit on the joinder of claims. The harder questions follow: whether joined plaintiffs with no harassment or assault dispute of their own are also out of arbitration, whether courts can sever those claims with adequate process under Rule 7 or defendants must move to sever early in the suit, and how the Act’s “named representative of a class or in a collective action alleging such conduct” language applies to class actions, including why the reading that helps defendants fails because there is no such thing as a collective action for sexual harassment. The hour then turns to the Act’s pre-conditions: what counts as a “dispute,” which courts agree includes related theories like retaliation for a complaint of sexual harassment (Olivieri) but which will be litigated at the boundaries, such as the witness fired after an internal investigation or the accused harasser who sues for defamation; and what “alleging” means, where courts that import a 12(b)(6) or Iqbal standard misread a statute that says “alleging,” not “stating a claim,” and where the analogy to supplemental jurisdiction and a proposed “non-frivolous” standard favor plaintiffs. Policy and legislative-history arguments from a Congress legislating in the wake of MeToo, narrative appeals to “judicial experience and common sense,” and the open issues the plaintiff’s bar has not yet picked up round out the session.

    John S. Crain

MCLE Credits

  • Alabama

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Alaska

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.

  • Arizona

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Arkansas

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • California

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Colorado

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Connecticut

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Delaware

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • District of Columbia

    No MCLE Required

    2 CLE Hour(s)

  • Florida

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General Hours

    Receive CLE credit in Florida via attorney submission.

  • Georgia

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Hawaii

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Idaho

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Illinois

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Indiana

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Iowa

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Kansas

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 Substantive

  • Kentucky

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Louisiana

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Maine

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Maryland

    No MCLE Required

    2 CLE Hour(s)

  • Massachusetts

    No MCLE Required

    2 CLE Hour(s)

  • Michigan

    No MCLE Required

    2 CLE Hour(s)

  • Minnesota

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Mississippi

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Missouri

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2.4 General

  • Montana

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Nebraska

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

    myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.

  • Nevada

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • New Hampshire

    Approved for CLE Credits

    120 General minutes

    As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.

  • New Jersey

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2

  • New Mexico

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • New York

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.

  • North Carolina

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • North Dakota

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14

  • Ohio

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Oklahoma

    Pending CLE Approval

    2.5 General

  • Oregon

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Pennsylvania

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Rhode Island

    Pending CLE Approval

    2.5 General

  • South Carolina

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • South Dakota

    No MCLE Required

    2 CLE Hour(s)

  • Tennessee

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Texas

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Utah

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Vermont

    Approved for CLE Credits

    2 General

  • Virginia

    Not Eligible

    2 General Hours

  • Washington

    Approved via Attorney Submission

    2 Law & Legal Hours

    Receive CLE credit in Washington via attorney submission.

  • West Virginia

    Pending CLE Approval

    2.4 General

  • Wisconsin

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General

  • Wyoming

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 General