On-Demand · October 24, 2025

Ethical Dilemma: Client Consent Does Not Determine Reasonableness of Fees

Professional fee reasonableness in bankruptcy: examining court oversight, structural barriers to fee challenges, and data-driven review methods.

Nancy B. Rapoport William S. Boyd School of LawRobert J. Keach Verrill Dana LLPJoseph Tiano Legal Decoder

About this program

Course Overview

Navigating Professional Fee Reasonableness in Bankruptcy

Participants will learn how courts evaluate professional fee reasonableness when compensation comes from bankruptcy estates rather than clients. This knowledge enables practitioners to improve billing practices and navigate fee examination processes effectively.

  • Court Oversight Understand Section 330 requirements beyond client consent.
  • Structural Barriers Recognize repeat player dynamics affecting fee challenges.
  • Fee Examination Apply two-component reasonableness analysis to billing.
  • Data Analytics Leverage algorithmic tools for efficient fee review.

Why Attend

Understanding bankruptcy professional fee reasonableness is essential because practitioners must navigate complex court oversight, ethics obligations, and emerging AI considerations to protect estate assets and creditor recoveries.

  • 61% Of large Chapter 11 bankruptcy cases filed since October 2009 were filed in just two jurisdictions—Southern District of New York and District of Delaware. (GAO Report GAO-15-839)
  • 96% Of Chapter 7 bankruptcy cases have no assets to distribute, meaning the trustee only receives the $60 flat fee with no commission. (Nolo Legal Encyclopedia)
  • 15.7% Potential increase in small-business creditor recovery if trustee commissions were reduced to optimal levels, according to structural economic modeling. (Review of Financial Studies, Samuel Antill, December 2024)
  • $6B Total fees and expenses incurred in Lehman Brothers Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings alone, the largest bankruptcy filing in U.S. history. (Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Liberty Street Economics)

Key Topics

  • Client Consent Client consent does not override unreasonable fees when third parties bear costs.
  • Structural Barriers Repeat player dynamics discourage estate-paid professionals from objecting to each other's fees.
  • Fee Examination Fee examiners evaluate whether actions were reasonable and work was done efficiently.
  • Data Analysis Algorithms benchmark tasks against comparable data to identify appropriate staffing and timing.
  • AI Impact Artificial intelligence tools may make failing to use technology itself unreasonable.
  • Case Efficiency The profession is evolving toward faster case processing and pre-negotiated arrangements.

What You Will Learn and Gain

What you will learn

Attorneys will learn why client consent alone cannot determine fee reasonableness in bankruptcy, where compensation comes from the estate and requires court oversight.

What you will gain

Attorneys will gain understanding of how fee examiners use data-driven analysis and human judgment to evaluate whether professional fees meet Section 330 requirements.

Speakers

Nancy B. Rapoport

Nancy B. Rapoport

William S. Boyd School of Law

Robert J. Keach

Robert J. Keach

Verrill Dana LLP

Experienced and widely respected bankruptcy practitioner focusing on bankruptcy, reorganization, and workouts, representing debtors, creditors, creditors’ committees, lessors, and third parties acquiring troubled companies.

Full profile

Experience

Practiced before bankruptcy courts in Districts of New Jersey, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Delaware, Northern District of California, Eastern District of Pennsylvania, and Southern and Eastern Districts of New York; served as court-appointed fee examiner; served as chapter 11 trustee; represented court-appointed receivers in matters before state courts including Delaware Chancery Court

Education

Adjunct Professor (Cross-Border Insolvency; Business Bankruptcy) at Boston College Law School

Recognition

Author of several articles on bankruptcy and creditors' rights appearing in the ABI Law Review, Commercial Law Journal, ABI Journal, and other publications; regularly appears as panelist on national bankruptcy, lender liability, and creditors' rights programs; designated expert witness on fee-related matters in several cases

Professional involvement

Admitted to practice in state and federal courts in Maine and Massachusetts; admitted to First, Second, Seventh and Eighth Circuit Courts of Appeals and the Supreme Court of the United States
Joseph R. Tiano, Jr

Joseph R. Tiano, Jr

Legal Decoder

Joseph R. Tiano, Jr., Esq. is the Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Legal Decoder, Inc. After practicing law for nearly 20 years, Joe founded Legal Decoder because he saw that clients and their law firms lacked the analytic tools and data to effectively price and manage the cost of legal services delivered by outside counsel. He set out to build an intelligent, data-driven technology company that would revolutionize the way legal services from outside counsel are priced and economically evaluated. Legal Decoder’s data analytics technology is used in law firms of all sizes from AmLaw 50 law firms to boutique firms, in Fortune 500 legal departments, and in major lawsuits and Chapter 11 bankruptcy cases, including PG&E, Purdue Pharma, Toys R Us, and Rite Aid, where legal fees are scrutinized.

Full profile

Experience

Joe practiced law for nearly 20 years before founding Legal Decoder. He was previously a Partner at Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman, LLP and Thelen LLP, where he grew and managed all aspects of a multi-million-dollar cross-border finance practice. His career began as a venture capital lawyer representing transformative technology companies, including Blackboard Inc. and many of the outgrowths of Blackboard (WeddingWire/The Knot, Presidium, Starfish Retention Solutions, and others).

Education

Joe received his J.D. from the University of Pittsburgh School of Law in 1995 and graduated from Georgetown University in 1992 with a Bachelor of Science Degree in Business Administration.

Recognition

Joe has been recognized as a 2026 LawDragon Top 100 AI & Legal Tech Advisor, a 2025 ACC Value Champion, and the TVPi 2025 Pricing Expert of the Year. He is also an Adjunct Professor of Law at the Arizona State University Sandra Day O'Connor Law School, currently teaching a course on Artificial Intelligence & Legal Ethics to 2L and 3L students.

Professional involvement

Joe is a prolific author, having (co-)authored a forthcoming West Academic textbook on AI and legal ethics and eleven law review articles published in scholarly journals. He has written articles for numerous blogs and other online media on substantive legal issues and the legal industry and regularly presents at CLEs and other seminars and courses on topics ranging from artificial intelligence, LegalTech, and legal data analytics to legal ethics and legal malpractice.

Agenda

  1. Session 1 · 11:30 am - 12:00 pm

    Client Consent vs. Court Oversight in Bankruptcy Fees

    This session examines why client approval alone cannot determine fee reasonableness when compensation flows from the bankruptcy estate rather than the client’s pocket. Participants will explore how ABA Model Rule 1.5 and Section 330 of the Bankruptcy Code establish the framework for judicial review, and how emerging AI tools are reshaping the reasonableness calculus.

    Nancy B. Rapoport, Robert J. Keach, Joseph R. Tiano, Jr

  2. Session 2 · 12:00 pm - 12:30 pm

    Structural Barriers to Professional Fee Challenges

    This session analyzes the repeat-player dynamics and professional relationships that discourage estate-paid professionals from objecting to each other’s fee applications. Participants will examine how CRO arrangements, administrative insolvency trends, and lender concerns create structural disincentives that compromise the integrity of organic fee review processes.

    Nancy B. Rapoport, Robert J. Keach, Joseph R. Tiano, Jr

  3. Break · 12:30 pm - 12:40 pm

    Break

    A short intermission allowing participants to refresh before the final session on data-driven fee examination.

    Nancy B. Rapoport, Robert J. Keach, Joseph R. Tiano, Jr

  4. Session 3 · 12:40 pm - 1:10 pm

    Data-Driven Analysis and Fee Examiner Best Practices

    This session explores how fee examiners use algorithmic analysis and benchmarking data to support courts in evaluating fee reasonableness under statutory requirements. Participants will learn about the two-component reasonableness test—whether actions were justified and whether work was performed efficiently—and why human judgment remains essential alongside data-driven tools.

    Nancy B. Rapoport, Robert J. Keach, Joseph R. Tiano, Jr

MCLE Credits

  • Alabama

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Alaska

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.

  • Arizona

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Professional Responsibility/Ethics

  • Arkansas

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • California

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • Colorado

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Connecticut

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Delaware

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Enhanced Ethics

  • District of Columbia

    No MCLE Required

    No MCLE Required

  • Florida

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics Hours

    Receive CLE credit in Florida via Attorney Submission.

  • Georgia

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • Hawaii

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Idaho

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Illinois

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 Ethics, Civility, Professionalism

  • Indiana

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Iowa

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Kansas

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Kentucky

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Louisiana

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Maine

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Maryland

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Massachusetts

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Michigan

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Minnesota

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • Mississippi

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Missouri

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.8 Ethics

  • Montana

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Professional Fitness and Integrity

  • Nebraska

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Professional Responsibility

    myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.

  • Nevada

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • New Hampshire

    Approved for CLE Credits

    90 Ethics / Professionalism minutes

    As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.

  • New Jersey

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2

  • New Mexico

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • New York

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.

  • North Carolina

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • North Dakota

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics

    Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14

  • Ohio

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 Professional Conduct

  • Oklahoma

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Oregon

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Pennsylvania

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • Rhode Island

    Pending CLE Approval

    2 Ethics / Professionalism

  • South Carolina

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • South Dakota

    No MCLE Required

    1.5 CLE Hour(s)

  • Tennessee

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Dual

  • Texas

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics

  • Utah

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Vermont

    Approved for CLE Credits

    1.5 Ethics

  • Virginia

    Not Eligible

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism Hours

  • Washington

    Approved via Attorney Submission

    1.5 Ethics Hours

    Receive CLE credit in Washington via Attorney Submission. myLawCLE will supply Washington state attorneys with instructions on how to gain credit.

  • West Virginia

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.8 Ethics / Professionalism

  • Wisconsin

    Approved for Self-Study Credits

    1.5 General

    Ethics credits can ONLY be earned through Live-Webcast programs, the Wisconsin Board of Bar Examiners does not approve Ethics through On-Demand sessions.

  • Wyoming

    Pending CLE Approval

    1.5 Ethics / Professionalism